Quintero Alvarez v. Baltazar, et al. (Amicus)

  • Filed: Nov 8, 2026
  • Status: In federal trial court
  • Court: U.S. District Court for the District of Colorado
  • Latest Update: Nov 9, 2026
In the Courts, ACLU of Colorado logo on a blue background with a woman holding the scales of justice.

Summary


In Colorado, ICE has arrested people without warrants and without probable cause, in violation of the law and court orders, and has instituted a policy and practice of “sham releases” instead of complying with court orders. In response to these “sham releases,” we filed an amicus brief and the Court granted our emergency motion to appear and argue at an evidentiary hearing on November 9. At the hearing, ICE committed to ending its unlawful policy of sham releases.


In Colorado and across the country, ICE arrests people without warrants and without probable cause in violation of the law and court orders. In a new escalation of its defiance of the law and the courts, ICE instituted a policy and practice of “sham releases” instead of complying with court orders to release someone ICE unlawfully arrests. In response to these “sham releases,” we filed an amicus brief in Quintero Alvarez v. Baltazar, et al. and the Court granted our motion to appear and argue at the evidentiary hearing on November 9.

The court documents detail how ICE gathered a group of men on October 27 and told them they were being released from the GEO detention facility in Aurora, but instead they were kept in ICE custody and then put back in detention shortly after their false “release.” The men, who had been ordered released by a federal judge, were forced out of the gates of the GEO facility and then immediately swarmed by ICE officers who told them they were once again under arrest. ICE repeated the same cruel sham no less than 18 times from October to early November.

U.S. District Court Judge Charlotte Sweeney ordered the ICE Field Office Director for Denver, Nathan Rasper, to appear in court on Monday, November 9, to address these violations. On Sunday, November 8, Judge Sweeney also granted the emergency motion for the ACLU of Colorado, and Jordan, to appear and argue at the hearing.

Jordan and the ACLU of Colorado are aware of at least 18 cases in Colorado where ICE has held people in detention who courts have ordered be released. In one case, a man who petitioned the courts for his release, and was granted it, described the terrifying moment when he was supposed to be released, but was arrested and taken back into detention. The petitioner in Lebrun v. Baltazar described ICE agents turning off their body cameras when he asked what was happening to him and then being threatened with criminal prosecution. In another case, the man described getting excited to see his family, then not even making it to the sidewalk outside the detention facility before he was taken back into custody.

At the hearing on November 9, Jordan and ACLU of Colorado Legal Director, Tim Macdonald, presented argument to the Court about the devastating toll the sham releases have on the people and families of the people ICE kept in its custody. They also identified the gravity of the policy and how it violates due process, ICE’s own regulations, and court orders. Finally, they noted how this policy and practice is ICE’s newest attempt to evade the law’s requirement to conduct a flight risk assessment before arresting people without a warrant. At the hearing, ICE and the government attorneys stated on the record that the practice of sham releases was over.


Media:

Case Number:
26-cv-04891-CNS
Judge:
Hon. Charlotte Sweeney
Attorney(s):
Tim Macdonald, Conor Gleason, and Sara Neel
Pro Bono Firm:
Professor Elizabeth Jordan

Learn More About the Issues in This Case