Tim Macdonald Headshot

Tim Macdonald

Legal Director

he/him

U.S. District Court Judge Charlotte Sweeney issued an order on Wednesday, November 18, 2026, that found Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents had violated court orders by falsely claiming to “release” people, only to keep them in federal custody. Specifically, ICE agents had forcibly escorted people outside the door of the Aurora GEO detention facility and back into the waiting arms of other ICE agents still within the gated area of the facility, where the agents would handcuff them and escort them back into the detention facility.

The following statement can be attributed to Tim Macdonald, ACLU of Colorado legal director:

“ICE has consistently abused its authority in violating court orders and the law. Colorado federal courts have affirmed that ICE’s latest tactic of sham release and keeping people in custody, despite court orders mandating their release, is patently unlawful and ridiculous. Release means release — period.

“Had this practice been permitted to continue, it would have eviscerated fundamental protections against arbitrary arrests and detention. Already, the Trump administration has broken the law to fulfil arrest quotas that have terrorized our communities. This welcome ruling affirms that these practices are unacceptable and deserve condemnation. As one federal judge pointed out, the abject cruelty of these policies seems to be the point.

“Now, our federal elected officials must use their powers to ensure this recklessness has consequences and hold ICE accountable, including through congressional investigations, passing laws to rein in ICE, curtailing no-strings-attached spending for the agency, and more.”

The ACLU of Colorado and law professor Elizabeth Jordan filed an amicus brief in Quintero Alvarez v. Baltazar, et al. on Saturday, November 7, 2026, urging the federal court to stop this practice. Jordan and the ACLU of Colorado identified at least 18 cases in Colorado where ICE has held people in detention who courts have ordered be released. Macdonald appeared in federal court on Monday, November 9, 2026, detailing how these sham releases have harmed people in ICE custody.

Related Content


Press Release
Nov 9, 2026
Placeholder image
  • Immigrant Justice

ACLU Of Colorado Files Emergency Motion After ICE Falsely Claims to Release People That Are Kept in Detention

ACLU of Colorado files Amicus Brief after ICE knowingly defied federal judges’ orders in at least seventeen separate cases in this district
Issue Areas: Immigrant Justice
Court Case
Nov 9, 2026
In the Courts, ACLU of Colorado logo on a blue background with a woman holding the scales of justice.
  • Immigrant Justice

Quintero Alvarez v. Baltazar, et al. (Amicus)

In Colorado, ICE has arrested people without warrants and without probable cause, in violation of the law and court orders, and has instituted a policy and practice of “sham releases” instead of complying with court orders. In response to these “sham releases,” we filed an amicus brief and the Court granted our emergency motion to appear and argue at an evidentiary hearing on November 9. At the hearing, ICE committed to ending its unlawful policy of sham releases.